Care Home Vs Homecare: How to Make The Right Choice

 In Blog

Care homes provide older adults with both a place to live and assistance with daily tasks. Staff are available to help residents with personal care needs like bathing, dressing, and taking medication. Home care offers personalised support within the individual’s own home. A carer visits regularly to assist with specific tasks as needed.

FeatureCare HomesHomecare
Level of CareRound-the-clock support, including medical care. Ideal for those with complex needs.Flexible care based on individual needs. May not be suitable for those with very complex medical requirements.
IndependenceLess independence due to shared living. Care homes aim to respect residents’ choices.Greater independence as the person stays in their own home.
Social InteractionBuilt-in community, activities, and chances to make friends.Less structured social interaction, but the person keeps their existing social circle.
CostOften fixed costs, covering everything from room to meals.Costs depend on the level of care needed, can be more variable.
Best Suited ForPeople needing: constant care, specialized medical attention, a strong social community.People needing: assistance with daily tasks, a flexible care plan, to remain in their own home.

As our loved ones age, it becomes increasingly important to consider their long-term care options. Two popular choices for elderly care are homecare and care homes. While both options have their merits, deciding which one is best suited for your loved one can be a daunting task. Making the choice between moving your loved one into a care home or opting for homecare is a decision that requires careful consideration and evaluation.

At Lidder Care we understand the significance of making the right choice for your loved ones. Renowned for our exceptional care services, we take pride in offering two esteemed care homes in Mansfield: Newgate Lodge Care Home and Lowmoor Nursing Home. With our commitment to compassionate care and a comfortable environment, we aim to guide individuals and their families in making the best choice for their unique needs.

This article will provide valuable insights to help you navigate this important decision with confidence and peace of mind, guaranteeing that you have made an informed decision.

Understanding Care Homes and Homecare

Residential and nursing care homes offer a supportive setting for people needing full-time care and help. These facilities are designed for a range of physical and cognitive needs, making sure residents are safe, comfortable, and well looked after.

Homecare lets people get support in their own familiar surroundings. Professional carers visit on a schedule that suits the individual. Homecare can cover anything from everyday help (like bathing and dressing) to specific needs like medication management or therapy.

Care Homes Vs Homecare

carer and respite resident on a bench in the garden

When choosing care, there’s a lot to think about. Start with your loved one’s needs and what they want. How much help do they need daily, and how important is independence? Consider their physical and mental abilities, and any health conditions. Homecare might be best if they need minimal help and want to stay in their own home. Care homes provide full-time support, which is better for complex care needs.

Social life and emotional well-being are also key. Care homes offer built-in companionship and activities. This sense of community can be a real boost. Think about what kind of social life your loved one enjoys. Homecare allows them to keep their usual connections while getting help that is personalised to them.

Costs are another major factor. Care homes often have fixed prices that cover everything. Homecare costs depend on how much support is needed. Look at both the immediate costs and what’s affordable in the long run. See if there are any financial aid programs that might help.

Care Homes

Care homes offer a lot, especially for those needing full-time care and support. One of the biggest benefits is having staff, including nurses, on hand all day and night. This gives peace of mind to both residents and their loved ones, knowing there’s always someone there if help is needed.

Many care homes also have specialised units or programmes designed for specific needs. These might be units for folks with dementia, programmes to help with recovery after an illness, or end-of-life care. This means residents get exactly the right support for their situation.

Another benefit is the sense of community. Residents can connect with others who understand what they’re going through. Having friends and activities helps fight off loneliness and makes life more enjoyable. Naturally, some people will miss the complete privacy of their own home. Good care homes go the extra mile to respect their residents’ choices and help them feel as independent as possible.

Adjusting to a new routine and surroundings can always be tough at first, and care homes are no exception. That’s why places like Newgate Lodge and Lowmoor Nursing Home focus on making the transition easier. Letting residents decorate their rooms the way they like it helps them feel at home. We also try our best to make schedules flexible, keeping residents’ needs at the heart of things.

  • 24/7 care: Staff, including nurses, are on hand day and night.
  • Specialised support: Many homes have dedicated units for dementia care, rehab, etc.
  • Community: Care homes offer friendship and activities to combat loneliness.
  • Respect: Good homes help residents make choices and feel independent.


Homecare’s biggest advantage is letting your loved one stay in their own familiar home while getting the support they need. It offers flexible, personalised care based on what they need that day. Carers offer one-on-one attention and can adapt as needed. This could be anything from help with daily tasks like bathing and meals to more specialised care like managing medication.

With homecare, your loved one maintains more independence and control. They keep familiar routines, can make choices about their care, and have a say in how things are done. It also lets family be actively involved, whether that’s helping with care or making decisions. Of course, care homes take that caregiving burden off family, letting them focus on just being there for their loved one.

One downside of homecare is that it might not be suitable for very complex medical needs. If someone needs advanced treatments, a nursing home like Lowmoor might be necessary. It’s also important to choose a reliable homecare agency with well-qualified carers. Background checks and references are a must.

  • Flexibility: Homecare offers personalised care plans that adjust to your loved one’s needs.
  • Independence: Allows greater control over daily routines and decision-making.
  • Familiarity: Care takes place in the comfort of the person’s own home.
  • Family Involvement: Enables active participation by family members in care processes.
  • Limitations: May not be suitable for complex medical needs requiring specialised facilities.
  • Reliability: Important to select a reputable homecare agency with qualified and vetted caregivers.

Making the Right Choice

Choosing the right care is important, so let’s talk through the options together. It’s about finding the perfect balance of support, social life, costs, and how much your loved one wants to be involved in decisions. Open conversations with them are key – this is their life, after all!

Getting extra advice is always a good idea. Talk to your doctor or an eldercare specialist to get the full picture. It’s also smart to really look into different care homes or homecare agencies. Visit a few places to get a feel for what they offer. What matters most is that your loved one feels safe, happy, and cared for in a way that’s right for them.

Lidder Care is committed to assisting individuals and their families in making the right choice, offering guidance, and answering any questions you may have. You can get in touch by calling 01623 622322 or by emailing